top of page

Unveiling the Vanilla World:Understanding the Difference Between Vanilla Extract and Essence


In the realm of culinary delights, vanilla holds a special place. Its sweet, comforting aroma and rich flavour have made it a beloved ingredient in a wide range of dishes, from baked goods to custards and beyond. When it comes to vanilla, you may have encountered two main players: vanilla extract and vanilla essence. This article elucidates the disparities between these two vanilla products and explores their interchangeability.

Vanilla Extract: The Purity of Nature

What is Vanilla Extract?

Vanilla extract is the essence of pure vanilla captured in liquid form. It is meticulously crafted by soaking vanilla beans in a mixture of water and ethyl alcohol. The defining character of vanilla extract is derived from vanillin, a key molecule found within vanilla beans. The extraction process involves an infusion of these compounds into the liquid medium. The standards for pure vanilla extract may vary by country, but in the United States, it must contain at least 35% alcohol and a specific quantity of vanilla beans per gallon.

Making Vanilla Extract: A Patient Endeavour

The creation of pure vanilla extract is a testament to patience and craftsmanship. It commences with mature vanilla bean pods, aged for several months to develop their characteristic flavours. These cured pods are then introduced into a blend of water and ethyl alcohol. Over time, the alcohol extracts the vanillin and other flavourful compounds from the beans, resulting in the distinctive taste we associate with vanilla. While commercial production can expedite the extraction process, homemade vanilla extract requires months of aging.

Vanilla Essence: An Artifice of Flavour

Understanding Vanilla Essence

In contrast to vanilla extract, vanilla essence, also known as artificial vanilla extract, follows a more processed path. It typically includes a blend of water, ethanol, propylene glycol, emulsifiers, and synthetic flavours and colours. Although it still relies on vanillin for its flavour, this vanillin is chemically produced, rendering it significantly less expensive than vanilla beans. Contrary to a common misconception, castoreum, a secretion from beavers with a vanilla-like scent, is seldom used in food and is not a prevalent ingredient in vanilla essence.

Can You Substitute Vanilla Essence for Vanilla Extract?

The interchangeability of vanilla essence and vanilla extract hinges on the dish you are preparing and your taste preferences. While vanilla essence can substitute for vanilla extract without disrupting the structural integrity of your recipe, it may introduce discernible differences in flavour.

The nuance lies in the complexity of taste that pure vanilla extract imparts. Vanilla beans contain over 200 compounds contributing to their flavour and aroma, resulting in a more intricate profile. This difference becomes particularly noticeable in dishes that are either uncooked or cooked at low heat. In such cases, it is advisable to employ pure vanilla extract for a richer, more profound vanilla essence.

On the other hand, for baked goods where the primary focus is not on vanilla flavour, such as chocolate chip cookies or carrot cake, vanilla essence can serve as a suitable substitute.

Recommended Uses: Extract or Essence?

To guide your selection between vanilla extract and vanilla essence, consider the following recommendations:

  • Vanilla Cake: Opt for vanilla extract.

  • Chocolate Cake: Vanilla essence is a suitable choice.

  • Chocolate Chip Cookies: Vanilla essence works well.

  • Iced Coffee: Vanilla extract is preferable.

  • Cheesecake: Vanilla essence complements nicely.

  • Vanilla Ice Cream: Choose vanilla extract.

  • Homemade Frosting or Icing: Vanilla extract is ideal.

  • Vanilla Pudding: Vanilla extract enhances the flavour.

  • Chocolate Pudding: Vanilla essence can suffice.

Generally, vanilla extract is best suited for dishes where vanilla is the star of the show or those cooked at lower temperatures. Conversely, vanilla essence is a reasonable alternative when a potent vanilla punch is not required.

Crafting Your Own Vanilla Extract

For those who relish homemade creations, crafting vanilla extract is a delightful endeavour. Here is a straightforward recipe to make your own:


- 3–6 vanilla bean pods

- 8 ounces (240 mL) of vodka


1. Slice each vanilla bean pod in half.

2. In a sanitised jar or bottle with an airtight lid, place the vanilla bean pods and cover them with vodka.

3. Seal the container and store it in a cool, dark location, such as your pantry, for a minimum of 6 weeks, up to 12 months.

4. When you are ready to use the extract, remove the vanilla beans.

5. The quantity of vanilla beans used will influence the strength of the extract, so consider your preference. Periodically shaking the container can enhance the extraction process.

Conclusion: Savour the Flavour

In the culinary realm, vanilla extract and vanilla essence are both valued for their ability to enhance flavours. While vanilla extract offers a more intricate and robust taste, vanilla essence can adeptly step in for most recipes. Whether you opt for the purity of extract or the efficiency of essence, the choice lies in your culinary vision. So, indulge in the sweet charm of vanilla, knowing that your creations will continue to delight the senses.


bottom of page